Brother Cadfael is a Welsh monk with a past. Before he took his vows at Shrewsbury Abbey, he was a crusader, a sailor, and a soldier, and he brings everything he learned in the world to the quiet work of his herb garden and, far more often than his prior would like, to solving murders.
Ellis Peters wrote twenty novels and one short story collection about Cadfael between 1977 and 1994, and together they helped create the modern historical mystery. This guide gives you the complete Brother Cadfael reading order, with a summary of every book, where to start, how the series fits into the real history of twelfth-century England, and what to read when you have finished.
This page contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Quick Series Facts
| Author | Ellis Peters (Edith Pargeter) |
| Number of Books | 21 (20 novels and 1 short story collection) |
| First Book | A Morbid Taste for Bones (1977) |
| Latest Book | Brother Cadfael’s Penance (1994) |
| Status | Complete |
| Setting | Shrewsbury and the Welsh borders, 1137 to 1145 |
| Genre | Historical mystery |
Brother Cadfael Books in Publication Order
1. A Morbid Taste for Bones (1977)
Setting: Shrewsbury Abbey and Gwytherin, Wales, 1137
The ambitious Prior Robert leads an expedition into Wales to bring the bones of Saint Winifred back to Shrewsbury, where they will bring the abbey prestige and pilgrims. Cadfael goes along as interpreter. When the village lord who opposes the plan is found dead, Cadfael has to find the killer before the dispute turns into something worse.
This first book was written as a standalone, and it shows. It is slightly different in tone from the rest of the series, but it introduces Cadfael’s wit, his Welsh roots, and his very flexible sense of justice.
2. One Corpse Too Many (1979)
Setting: Shrewsbury, August 1138
King Stephen besieges Shrewsbury Castle, and when it falls, he orders the garrison hanged. Cadfael is given the grim job of preparing the bodies for burial and finds one more corpse than there should be, a man who was murdered rather than executed.
This is where the series truly begins. It introduces Hugh Beringar, the clever young nobleman who becomes Cadfael’s closest friend and partner in solving crimes, and it establishes the civil war between Stephen and the Empress Maud as the backdrop for everything that follows.
3. Monk’s Hood (1980)
Setting: Shrewsbury, December 1138
A wealthy landowner who has promised his property to the abbey dies after eating a dish sent from the abbot’s kitchen. The poison is oil of monk’s hood, taken from Cadfael’s own workshop. To make matters more personal, the dead man’s widow is Richildis, the woman Cadfael was engaged to before he left for the Crusades.
Monk’s Hood won the Crime Writers’ Association Silver Dagger and is one of the most popular books in the series. The plot also turns on the differences between English and Welsh inheritance law, which Peters uses brilliantly.
4. Saint Peter’s Fair (1981)
Setting: Shrewsbury, summer 1139
The townspeople of Shrewsbury want a share of the profits from the abbey’s annual fair, and tempers run high. When a wealthy merchant from Bristol is murdered during the fair, Cadfael discovers that the crime is tangled up with the political struggle between Stephen and the Empress.
The book gives a lively picture of medieval trade and town life, and it introduces the merchant’s niece, Emma, one of Peter’s most memorable young heroines.
5. The Leper of Saint Giles (1981)
Setting: Shrewsbury, October 1139
An elderly baron arrives to marry a young heiress at the abbey, and the whole town disapproves. When the bridegroom is found murdered in the forest before the wedding, suspicion falls on the young squire who loves the bride. Cadfael’s investigation leads him to the leper hospital of Saint Giles on the edge of town.
This is one of the most moving books in the series, with a mystery that turns on compassion as much as deduction.
6. The Virgin in the Ice (1982)
Setting: Shropshire, November to December 1139
After the city of Worcester is sacked, two noble orphans and the young nun escorting them disappear into the winter countryside. Cadfael is sent to find them and makes a terrible discovery in a frozen stream.
The book is also a turning point in Cadfael’s personal story. It introduces Olivier de Bretagne, a young knight with a connection to Cadfael’s crusading past, and the revelation is one of the emotional highlights of the entire series.
7. The Sanctuary Sparrow (1983)
Setting: Shrewsbury, spring 1140
A young traveling juggler bursts into the abbey church during the night office, pursued by a mob who accuse him of robbery and murder at a goldsmith’s wedding. He claims sanctuary, and Cadfael has forty days to prove his innocence.
It is a tight, well-plotted mystery that explores the medieval right of sanctuary and the gap between townspeople and outsiders.
8. The Devil’s Novice (1983)
Setting: Shrewsbury and the surrounding manors, September 1140
A young man named Meriet Aspley enters the abbey as a novice, but his nightmares disturb the whole dormitory, and his brothers begin to call him the devil’s novice. At the same time, a royal envoy has vanished on his way through Shropshire.
Cadfael suspects the two mysteries are connected. The book is a sensitive portrait of a troubled young man and one of the best character studies in the series.
9. Dead Man’s Ransom (1984)
Setting: Shrewsbury and the Welsh border, February 1141
King Stephen has been captured at the Battle of Lincoln, and Shropshire’s sheriff, Gilbert Prestcote, has been taken prisoner by the Welsh. A prisoner exchange is arranged, but when the sheriff is murdered in the abbey infirmary, the peace is thrown into doubt.
This book reshapes the political situation in Shrewsbury for the rest of the series, and it marks an important moment for Hugh Beringar.
10. The Pilgrim of Hate (1984)
Setting: Shrewsbury, May 1141
Pilgrims gather at the abbey to celebrate the anniversary of Saint Winifred’s arrival. Among them is a young man walking barefoot to Aberdaron in penance, and his watchful companion. Meanwhile, news arrives of a murder in Winchester connected to the Empress’s attempt to take the crown.
The book is gentler than most, with a strong focus on faith and forgiveness, and it was the last Cadfael novel adapted for television.
11. An Excellent Mystery (1985)
Setting: Shrewsbury, August 1141
After the destruction of Winchester, two monks from the burned abbey of Hyde Mead arrive at Shrewsbury: the dying Brother Humilis, a former crusader, and the young mute Brother Fidelis who cares for him. Humilis once had a betrothed who vanished, and her family wants to know what became of her.
Many readers consider this the finest book in the series, and its ending is one of Peters’ best.
12. The Raven in the Foregate (1986)
Setting: Shrewsbury, December 1141
Abbot Radulfus appoints a new priest to the parish of Holy Cross, but Father Ailnoth is harsh and unforgiving, and within weeks, he has alienated his whole congregation. When he is found dead in the mill pond at Christmas, there is no shortage of suspects.
It is a strong, character-driven mystery about power, pride, and the kind of religion that forgets mercy.
13. The Rose Rent (1986)
Setting: Shrewsbury, June 1142
A young widow, Judith Perle, has given her house to the abbey for the yearly rent of a single white rose from the bush in its garden. As the day for paying the rent approaches, the rose bush is attacked, and a young monk is found dead beside it.
The novel is rich in detail about the medieval wool and cloth trades, and Judith is one of the series’ most memorable characters.
14. The Hermit of Eyton Forest (1987)
Setting: Shropshire, October 1142
Young Richard Ludel, a pupil at the abbey school, has just inherited his father’s estate. His ambitious grandmother wants to marry him off to a neighbor’s daughter, and a mysterious hermit has settled on her land. When a stranger hunting a runaway servant is killed in the forest, Cadfael has to untangle the plot.
The book’s backdrop is the Empress’s desperate position in besieged Oxford, and the politics of the Anarchy are close to the surface.
15. The Confession of Brother Haluin (1988)
Setting: Shropshire and Hales, December 1142 to early 1143
Brother Haluin is badly injured in a fall while repairing the abbey roof, and believing himself dying, confesses a sin from his youth. When he recovers, he sets out on a winter pilgrimage to make amends, and Cadfael goes with him.
This is more of a journey than a traditional whodunit, and it takes Cadfael away from Shrewsbury for most of the story.
16. A Rare Benedictine (1988)
Setting: Various, 1120 to 1140
A collection of three short stories. The first, “A Light on the Road to Woodstock,” tells how Cadfael came to Shrewsbury Abbey and why a soldier and a sailor chose to become monks. The other two, “The Price of Light” and “Eye Witness,” are short mysteries set during his early years at the abbey.
Although published in the sixteenth century, this collection contains the earliest events in Cadfael’s story. See the chronological order section below for the reading order.
17. The Heretic’s Apprentice (1989)
Setting: Shrewsbury, June 1143
Young Elave returns from a long pilgrimage, bringing his master’s body home for burial. But his outspoken questions about faith soon lead to an accusation of heresy, and when a man is murdered, Elave becomes the obvious suspect.
The novel explores medieval ideas about heresy and free thought, with Abbot Radulfus at his most thoughtful.
18. The Potter’s Field (1989)
Setting: Shrewsbury, August 1143
When the abbey begins plowing a field it has just acquired, the plow turns up the remains of a woman. The land once belonged to a potter who left his wife to become a monk, and suspicion falls on him.
It is a quiet, sad mystery with a strong focus on the people left behind by religious vocations.
19. The Summer of the Danes (1991)
Setting: Gwynedd, Wales, April 1144 onward
Cadfael travels to Wales on church business with his former assistant, Brother Mark, and is caught up in a feud between the Welsh prince Owain Gwynedd and his troublesome brother Cadwaladr, who has brought Danish mercenaries from Dublin.
This is the most adventurous book in the series, with Cadfael taken prisoner and much less emphasis on murder. It is a treat for readers who love Welsh history.
20. The Holy Thief (1992)
Setting: Shrewsbury and Ramsey, February 1145
Monks driven from Ramsey Abbey by the outlaw baron Geoffrey de Mandeville arrive at Shrewsbury seeking help to rebuild. When they leave, Saint Winifred’s reliquary disappears with them, and a murder follows.
The book brings the series back to Saint Winifred, whose relics began the story in A Morbid Taste for Bones.
21. Brother Cadfael’s Penance (1994)
Setting: Coventry and Gloucestershire, November 1145
Olivier de Bretagne has been captured and imprisoned after a betrayal in the civil war, and no one knows where he is being held. To find him, Cadfael breaks his vows and leaves the abbey without permission, knowing he may never be allowed to return.
This is the final Cadfael novel and a fitting conclusion. It is best read last, after you have come to know Cadfael and everything he stands to lose.
Upcoming Books
The series is complete. Ellis Peters died in 1995, the year after Brother Cadfael’s Penance was published, and no continuation novels have been authorized. There are no more Cadfael books to come.
Chronological Order vs Publication Order
The Cadfael novels were written in almost exact chronological order, with each book set a few months after the last. The one exception is A Rare Benedictine, which was published in the sixteenth century but contains the earliest stories, beginning in 1120.
Chronological order:
- A Rare Benedictine (stories set 1120 to 1140)
- A Morbid Taste for Bones (1137)
- One Corpse Too Many (1138)
- Then books 3 to 21 in the same order as publication
Our recommendation: read in publication order. A Rare Benedictine explains how Cadfael became a monk, but its stories work better once you already know him and the abbey. If you want to read it early, the ideal spot is after One Corpse Too Many.
Companion Novels and Short Stories
A Rare Benedictine is the only collection of Cadfael short stories. Its three stories are:
- “A Light on the Road to Woodstock” (Cadfael’s decision to enter the abbey, 1120)
- “The Price of Light” (a mystery about a gift of silver candlesticks)
- “Eye Witness” (a robbery with an unexpected witness)
There are no other official Cadfael novels or stories. Readers who want more of Peters’ work can turn to her contemporary Felse mysteries, covered on our Ellis Peters author page.
A note on titles: some editions spell the third book Monk’s-Hood with a hyphen, and US editions sometimes use St. Peter’s Fair for the fourth. These are the same books.
About the Brother Cadfael Series
The Cadfael Chronicles follow a Benedictine monk at the Abbey of Saint Peter and Saint Paul in Shrewsbury during the civil war known as the Anarchy. Each novel is a self-contained mystery, but the series also tells a continuous story, following Cadfael, his friends, and the war over eight years.
Cadfael was born in Wales in 1080 and left home young. He fought in the First Crusade, spent years as a sailor in the Mediterranean, and served as a soldier before choosing the cloister in his forties. That experience gives him a practical wisdom and a tolerance for human weakness that sets him apart from many of his brothers.
What Makes Brother Cadfael Special
- A detective with a life before the mysteries. Cadfael has loved, fought, and traveled, and his past keeps returning in unexpected ways.
- A real historical backdrop. The Anarchy shapes every book, from the siege of Shrewsbury to the Battle of Lincoln and the rout of Winchester.
- Warmth and humor. Peters’ writing is gentle and often funny, especially in the scenes with the pompous Prior Robert and his sycophantic clerk, Brother Jerome.
- Justice over law. Cadfael cares more about what is right than about the letter of the law, and his solutions often protect the innocent in surprising ways.
- Young lovers in every book. Almost every novel features a young couple whose future depends on the solution, which gives the series its romantic warmth.
- A strong sense of place. Shrewsbury, the River Severn, and the Welsh hills are described so vividly that the books still draw visitors to the town.
Main Characters
- Brother Cadfael. Former crusader, sailor, and soldier, now the abbey’s herbalist.
- Hugh Beringar. A young nobleman who becomes deputy sheriff and later sheriff of Shropshire, and Cadfael’s closest friend.
- Abbot Radulfus. The strict but fair abbot who arrives in 1138 and comes to trust Cadfael’s judgment.
- Prior Robert and Brother Jerome. Cadfael’s ambitious superior and his gossiping assistant are the series’ comic foils.
- Brother Mark. Cadfael’s gentle young assistant in the herb garden, who later leaves to pursue the priesthood.
- Olivier de Bretagne. A young knight whose connection to Cadfael becomes central to the later books.
Where to Start
New Readers
Start with A Morbid Taste for Bones, the first book. It introduces Cadfael and the abbey and sets up the relics of Saint Winifred, which recur throughout the series.
Can You Start Elsewhere?
Yes. Every Cadfael novel is a self-contained mystery, and many readers first met him through a random library copy or the TV series. If you want to start with the strongest book, try One Corpse Too Many, which introduces Hugh Beringar and the Anarchy, or Monk’s Hood, the Silver Dagger winner.
The only books to save for later are The Virgin in the Ice, An Excellent Mystery, and Brother Cadfael’s Penance, which pay off long-running personal storylines and are much more rewarding in sequence.
Tips for Reading Cadfael
- Take your time. These are gentle, reflective mysteries, best enjoyed slowly.
- Do not worry about the politics. Peters explains what you need to know in each book, but a quick look at the timeline below makes the background easier to follow.
- Consider omnibus editions. The series is widely available in omnibus volumes of three books each, which are good value for readers planning to read the whole set.
About the Author
Ellis Peters was the pen name of Edith Pargeter, born in Horsehay, Shropshire, in 1913. She spent almost her entire life in Shropshire, and her deep knowledge of the county and its history shaped the Cadfael books from the start.
Pargeter had a long and varied career before Cadfael. She wrote historical novels under her own name, including the Brothers of Gwynedd quartet about thirteenth-century Wales, and a series of contemporary mysteries as Ellis Peters featuring the Felse family, one of which won the Edgar Award in 1963. She was also an award-winning translator of Czech literature.
She wrote the first Cadfael novel in her sixties, and the series made her famous worldwide. She received the Crime Writers’ Association’s Cartier Diamond Dagger for lifetime achievement in 1993 and an OBE in 1994, and she died in 1995. For her complete bibliography, see our Ellis Peters author page.
Historical Context
The Cadfael novels are set during the Anarchy, the civil war that tore England apart between 1135 and 1153. When King Henry I died in 1135, his only surviving legitimate child was his daughter, Matilda, known as the Empress (and called Maud in the novels). Before she could claim the throne, her cousin Stephen of Blois seized the crown, and the country split between them.
Shrewsbury felt the war directly. In 1138, Stephen really did besiege Shrewsbury Castle, which had been held for the Empress, and after it fell, he executed members of the garrison, the event at the heart of One Corpse Too Many. In 1141, Stephen was captured at the Battle of Lincoln, and the Empress came close to being crowned before the Londoners drove her out. Later that year, the rout at Winchester, where her ally Robert of Gloucester was captured, swung the war back again.
Many of the real events and people of the period appear in the books, including the 1138 arrival of Saint Winifred’s relics at Shrewsbury Abbey, Abbot Heribert and Abbot Radulfus, the Welsh prince Owain Gwynedd, and the outlaw baron Geoffrey de Mandeville. The war dragged on until the Treaty of Wallingford in 1153, which named the Empress’s son, Henry, as Stephen’s heir.
Accuracy note: Peters researched the period thoroughly, and the series’s political timeline closely follows real events. Cadfael and most of the murder plots are fiction, but the abbey, the town, the battles, and much of the daily life of monks, merchants, and townspeople are well-grounded in history.
A Quick Timeline of the Anarchy in the Novels
| Year | Real Event | Cadfael Book |
|---|---|---|
| 1137 | Saint Winifred’s relics sought for Shrewsbury | A Morbid Taste for Bones |
| 1138 | Stephen besieges Shrewsbury Castle | One Corpse Too Many |
| 1139 | The Empress prepares to land in England; Worcester sacked | Saint Peter’s Fair, The Virgin in the Ice |
| 1141 | Stephen captured at Lincoln; the rout of Winchester | Dead Man’s Ransom, An Excellent Mystery |
| 1142 | The Empress besieged at Oxford | The Hermit of Eyton Forest |
| 1144 | Welsh conflict between Owain Gwynedd and Cadwaladr | The Summer of the Danes |
| 1145 | Aftermath of Geoffrey de Mandeville’s revolt | The Holy Thief |
For more novels set in this era, see our guide to medieval Europe historical fiction and our list of the best medieval historical fiction.
Similar Series You’ll Love
Sharon Kay Penman‘s Justin de Quincy mysteries. Four medieval mysteries set in the 1190s, starring a young agent of Eleanor of Aquitaine. Penman’s When Christ and His Saints Slept also covers the Anarchy in epic form, making it a perfect companion to Cadfael.
C.J. Sansom‘s Shardlake series. A hunchbacked lawyer solves crimes in the dangerous world of Henry VIII. Darker and longer than Cadfael, but with the same mix of mystery, history, and a humane detective.
S.J. Parris‘s Giordano Bruno series. A former monk-turned-spy investigates murders in Elizabethan England. Readers who enjoy Cadfael’s blend of faith and detective work will find a lot to like.
Lindsey Davis‘s Falco series. A witty informer in ancient Rome. Much lighter and funnier, but with the same strong sense of place and period detail.
Anne Perry‘s William Monk series. Victorian rather than medieval, but a thoughtful detective with a troubled past and a strong moral compass.
Candace Robb’s Owen Archer series. A medieval mystery series set in fourteenth-century York, starring a one-eyed former archer turned apothecary’s apprentice. It is one of the closest in spirit to Cadfael.
Adaptations
The ITV Series (1994 to 1998)
Cadfael was adapted for television by Central for ITV, starring Sir Derek Jacobi as Brother Cadfael. Thirteen feature-length episodes were made across four series, filmed mainly in Hungary. In the United States, the series aired on PBS as part of Mystery!.
The adapted books are One Corpse Too Many, The Sanctuary Sparrow, The Leper of Saint Giles, Monk’s Hood, The Virgin in the Ice, The Devil’s Novice, A Morbid Taste for Bones, The Rose Rent, Saint Peter’s Fair, The Raven in the Foregate, The Holy Thief, The Potter’s Field, and The Pilgrim of Hate. The episodes were broadcast out of book order, and some changed the plots considerably.
Hugh Beringar was played by three different actors: Sean Pertwee in the first series, Eoin McCarthy in the second and third, and Anthony Green in the fourth.
Radio
BBC Radio 4 produced several Cadfael adaptations, with Philip Madoc voicing Cadfael in Monk’s Hood, The Virgin in the Ice, and Dead Man’s Ransom in the 1990s.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many Brother Cadfael books are there?
There are 21 Brother Cadfael books: 20 novels and one short story collection, A Rare Benedictine. The series ran from A Morbid Taste for Bones (1977) to Brother Cadfael’s Penance (1994).
What order should I read the Cadfael books in?
Read them in publication order, starting with A Morbid Taste for Bones and ending with Brother Cadfael’s Penance. The novels were written in chronological order, so publication order also follows the story. The only exception is the short story collection A Rare Benedictine, which contains earlier events but is best read after the first few novels.
What is the first Brother Cadfael book?
The first book is A Morbid Taste for Bones (1977), set in 1137, in which Cadfael travels to Wales with an expedition to bring Saint Winifred’s relics to Shrewsbury.
What is the last Brother Cadfael book?
The last is Brother Cadfael’s Penance (1994), set in 1145. Ellis Peters died in 1995, so it is the final novel in the series.
Do I have to read the Cadfael books in order?
No. Each novel is a complete mystery and can be read on its own. However, reading in order lets you follow the characters, especially Hugh Beringar and Olivier de Bretagne, and the progress of the civil war.
What is the best Brother Cadfael book?
Monk’s Hood won the CWA Silver Dagger and is a frequent favorite. Many readers also rank An Excellent Mystery, The Virgin in the Ice, and One Corpse Too Many among the best.
Are the Cadfael books historically accurate?
Largely, yes. The series closely follows the real events of the Anarchy, and Shrewsbury Abbey, Saint Winifred’s relics, and many political figures are historical figures. Cadfael himself and the murder plots are fictional.
Where is Brother Cadfael set?
The series is set mainly at the Benedictine abbey in Shrewsbury, Shropshire, and in the surrounding countryside and the Welsh borders, between 1137 and 1145.
How long does it take to read the Cadfael series?
The novels are fairly short, most around 200-300 pages. A steady reader can finish the whole series in a few months, and many readers like to read one between longer books.
Are the Cadfael books suitable for younger readers?
Yes, for most teenagers. There are murders, but violence is rarely graphic, and there is no explicit sexual content. The gentle tone makes them a good introduction to historical mysteries.
Is there a Brother Cadfael TV series?
Yes. ITV adapted 13 of the books between 1994 and 1998, starring Derek Jacobi as Cadfael. The series is available on DVD.
Will there be any new Cadfael books?
No. Ellis Peters died in 1995, and no continuation novels have been authorized. The 21 books are the complete series.
Are the Cadfael books available as audiobooks and ebooks?
Yes. The whole series is available in ebook and audiobook editions, and several omnibus print volumes collect three novels each.
Who was Ellis Peters?
Ellis Peters was the pen name of Edith Pargeter (1913 to 1995), a Shropshire-born novelist and translator. Besides Cadfael, she wrote the Felse mysteries and many historical novels under her own name.
Conclusion
The Brother Cadfael Chronicles remain the gold standard for historical mysteries. Ellis Peters combined clever puzzles, a vivid picture of twelfth-century England, and one of the most humane detectives in crime fiction, and the result has charmed readers for nearly fifty years.
Start with A Morbid Taste for Bones, read on in order, and save Brother Cadfael’s Penance for last. By the time you reach it, you will understand why so many readers still make the trip to Shrewsbury.
Related Content
- Ellis Peters: Complete Guide to Books & Series
- Best Historical Mystery Fiction
- Best Medieval Historical Fiction
- Medieval Europe Historical Fiction
- Sharon Kay Penman: Complete Guide to Books & Series
- C.J. Sansom: Complete Guide to Books & Series
- Best Historical Fiction Series